REPOZYTORIUM UNIWERSYTETU
W BIAŁYMSTOKU
UwB

Proszę używać tego identyfikatora do cytowań lub wstaw link do tej pozycji: http://hdl.handle.net/11320/2790
Tytuł: Korekcyjna funkcja słuszności w prawie rodzinnym – kilka refleksji na marginesie wyroku M.R & Anor -v- An tArd Chlaraitheoir & Ors
Inne tytuły: The corrective function of equity in family law – some reflections on the MR & Anor-v-An Tard Chlaraitheoir & Ors case
Autorzy: Bagan-Kurluta, Katarzyna
Oszkinis, Bartłomiej
Słowa kluczowe: equity
surrogate motherhood
Family Law
judical lawmaking
precedent
Polish Legal System
Data wydania: 2014
Data dodania: 5-maj-2015
Wydawca: Temida 2
Źródło: Białostockie Studia Prawnicze, z. 17, 2014, s. 13-30
Abstrakt: Processes occurring in the modern world such as the development of medically assisted procreation force lawyers to make decisions in the absence of explicit statutory regulations, or in the situation when the relevant provisions, however anachronic, operate – or in broader terms, when they threaten the fundamental values recognized by the community, even though at first glance it may appear that they are part of an axiology of the legal system. The equity rules play an important role in this context, allowing to provide the corrections of law. The reference to them is certainly not an easy task, especially when the consequence would be to give a ruling (at least prima facie), contra legem. However, perhaps because of such judgments we will approach the ideal of law understood as ars boni et aequi rejecting at the same time its vision, which can be described by another well-known maxim: summum ius summa iniuria. In the Irish case MR & Anor-v-An Tard Chlaraitheoir & Ors, the court has issued a precedent perhaps in the double sense of the term: thus – an event preceding and justifying other similar events in the future and the decision of the court serving as an example or justification for resolving similar issues or cases. The court assessed a broad context of an altruistic surrogacy agreement and made a decision that refl ects the objective truth about the origin of the children. Perhaps we will have to wait a long time for a similar ruling in Poland – perhaps under the current regime, it will never be issued.
Afiliacja: Katarzyna Bagan-Kurluta - Uniwersytet w Białymstoku
Bartłomiej Oszkinis - Uniwersytet w Białymstoku
URI: http://hdl.handle.net/11320/2790
DOI: 10.15290/bsp.2014.17.01
ISSN: 1689-7404
Typ Dokumentu: Article
Występuje w kolekcji(ach):Artykuły naukowe (WP)
Białostockie Studia Prawnicze, 2014, Z. 17

Pliki w tej pozycji:
Plik Opis RozmiarFormat 
BSP_17_2014_Bagan-Kurluta_Oszkinis.pdf353,04 kBAdobe PDFOtwórz
Pokaż pełny widok rekordu Zobacz statystyki


Pozycje w RUB są chronione prawem autorskim, z zastrzeżeniem wszelkich praw, chyba że zaznaczono inaczej.